Smokers For the Home User
|
There are two designs of smokers available in the market place.
Vertically or horizontally oriented, both types can be fueled by charcoal,
wood, electricity or gas. Vertical smokers usually have a water source to
dampen temperature and keep the interior of the smoking environment high
in humidity. This is important in keeping many tougher meats moist while
heat dissolves the fibrous collagen. Most horizontal smokers are typically
run dry, like the Stillwater (see below). Electric smokers are usually vertical
in orientation and typically have a water pan to keep moisture in the smoking environment
higher than dry heat.
The purpose of the Smokenator is to provide either a final or an interim
solution for a Barbecue Chef who already owns a 22” Weber and desires
to maximize the versatility, capacity and temperature control features that are
built into this classic American kettle.
Most people know that the Weber kettle has superior control of temperature.
What most people don’t realize is the capacity of the Weber can be easily
expanded. If you purchase a Smokenator and the Hovergrill or use an
alternative extra grill such as one used for the 18" Weber.
What capacity do you really have? How does this capacity meet your
personal needs? How does this capacity compare to other smokers on the
market? available
This picture illustrates the area to hold food of the 22.5” Weber
with a Smokenator installed.
|
|
 |
 |
The Hovergrill rests on two supports that raise the grill almost 3 inches
above the food support grill. The total area of the combined grills is 547
square inches. I have used the combination to smoke over 15 pounds of ribs.
|
 |
The Smokenator and Hovergrill combination with shipping amounts to about $70.00.
It’s only reasonable to ask what other kinds of smokers are out there that
compete with this combination?
|
|
 |
The Weber Smokey mountain is one of the
more popular vertical smokers in the
market primarily due to the users ability
to precisely control air intake to control
the rate of burning of the charcoal fuel.
The Smokenator comes with directions to allow
You to understand how to control the 22’ Weber the same way.
The Smokenator-Hovergrill combination
has about 10 square inches more surface
to hold food. Both the Weber kettle and
the Weber Smokey mountain have
temperature gradients.
Both systems have a water reservoir to
dampen heat and keep the environment
humid. If you already have a Weber kettle
you save space and $180.00!
You don't have to get on your knees to fill the water pan or tend to the coals
and no greasy clean up of the water pan! That alone saves 20 minutes of your time.
|
 |
The Brinkmann’s 2- 15.5” diameter grills
have 377 square inches of surface area,
about 68% less surface than the 547 square inches of the
Smokenator-Hovergrill combination. The Brinkman does not have any means to
control air to the charcoal except the ash that forms over the burning
charcoal. In fact one has to stir the coals on occasion to increase heat
roduction. Eventually, the coals get smothered in ash.
Both of these vertical smokers collect the drippings in the water pan
resting beneath the food support grills. It takes about 20 minutes to
clean this pan. In the Weber kettle drippings are absorbed in the ash
collecting under the coal support grill, one just sweeps ash and dripping
through the vents-No Messy clean up!
If you have one and want to learn how to modify it turn it into a good smoker
this website shows how.
|
 |
The New Braunfels Compact smoker is
a nice compact smoker which has 244
square inches of grill space. The 22”
Weber with just the food support grill
not counting the surface taken by the
Smokenator is 300 square inches.
One could buy a new 22” Weber One Touch for $84.00 and a Smokenator for
$45.00 and have a $100.00 left over! For spices, wood chunks, and remote thermometers.
One would save space and not clutter the patio.
|
 |
The Brinkmann Stillwater features a
grill area of 480 square inches and an
offset fire box. It’s a traditional smoker
with 1/4” steel walls! Cost? $920 and
includes a free $45.00 Value cover.
A Smokenator with a Hovergrill has 550
square inches. Cost $71.99 including
shipping. When you buy a Smokenator you get detailed
directions on how to set up the Weber
to run between 210 to 230°F.
Plus you won’t have to put up with cold
spots or making modifications that are common with
the these horizontal offset smokers.
|
 |
The New Braunfels/Charbroil Bandera Description:
• Vertical Smoker with Offset Firebox
• Heavy Duty Steel Construction
• 992 sq. in. of Cooking Space
• Heat Resistant Powder Coat Paint
• Convenient Front Shelf
• Dual-Air Damper System
• Cool Touch Handles
• Firebox Includes Cleanout Door
• Removable Ash Pan
• Lower Storage Rack
$599.
Now this is a smoker!!! You can go to the
Barbecue Brethren forum and get the modifications
that turn it into one heck
of a smoker. The Bandera's costs $0.60 per square inch of
smoking area. Cost of a Smokenator when you already have a 22” Weber? $0.15 a square inch.
Buy a Hovergrill you get 550 square inches of smoking surface for $0.10 a square inch.
|